Portal Login
Schedule a Call Pricing

Shareholders’ Agreements in Hong Kong: What Every Business Founder Should Know

Shareholders' Agreements in Hong Kong: What Every Business Founder Should Know

Shareholders' Agreements in Hong Kong: What Every Business Founder Should Know

Starting a business with another person can be an exciting opportunity. You may share the same vision, bring complementary skills and combine financial resources to build something with long-term potential.

However, agreeing to start a business together is only the beginning. Once a company has multiple shareholders, questions about ownership, control, funding, responsibilities and future exit arrangements become increasingly important.

For a Hong Kong startup with more than one shareholder, a shareholders’ agreement is critical because it fills gaps left by the public Articles of Association and provides a private, flexible framework to manage the relationship and expectations between shareholders and establishing clear expectations from the outset.

In this article, we explore why shareholders’ agreements matter, the provisions founders should consider and how these arrangements can support a business as it grows.

1. What Is a Shareholders' Agreement?

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contractual arrangement between the shareholders of a company. It sets out their agreed rights, responsibilities and obligations in relation to the company and one another.

While Hong Kong companies are governed by the Companies Ordinance and their Articles of Association, these documents do not necessarily address every commercial arrangement between founders and investors.

A shareholders’ agreement can provide additional detail on matters such as:

  • Ownership and shareholding arrangements.
  • Appointment of directors and management responsibilities.
  • Decisions requiring shareholder approval.
  • Funding obligations and future investment.
  • Voting Rights including separation of Shareholders and Directors Responsibilities & Reserved Matters
  • Share transfers and restrictions on ownership changes.
  • Founder vesting and leaver provisions.
  • Deadlock and dispute resolution.
  • Exit arrangements and pre-agreed valuation calculations on the sale of the business.

It is not a statutory requirement for every Hong Kong company. However, where multiple shareholders are involved, considering one at an early stage can help avoid uncertainty later.

2. Shareholders' Agreement vs Articles of Association: What Is the Difference?

One of the most important considerations when establishing a Hong Kong company is understanding the difference between its Articles of Association and a shareholders’ agreement.

Both documents play a role in company governance, but they serve different purposes.

Articles of Association

The Articles of Association are the company’s constitutional document. They establish the framework governing matters such as the company’s internal administration, directors’ powers, shareholder meetings, voting and share-related procedures.

A Hong Kong company must have Articles of Association when incorporated.

Shareholders’ Agreement

A shareholders’ agreement is a separate private contract between the parties who sign it. It can address commercial arrangements and personal obligations between the parties that may not be fully covered by the Articles of Association.

A shareholders’ agreement does not replace the Articles of Association nor override the Companies Ordinance.

The objective is to ensure that the documents work together rather than create uncertainty or conflicting obligations.

One important distinction is privacy. The Articles of Association are part of the company’s public corporate records, whereas a shareholders’ agreement is generally not filed with the Companies Registry.

This allows shareholders to document certain commercial arrangements privately.

For example, founders may want to agree on:

  • How long each founder is expected to remain actively involved.
  • What happens if a founder leaves the business.
  • What happens if a shareholder refuses to inject more working capital.
  • How is a share valued if a shareholder wants to sell.
  • What happens if a shareholder dies.
  • What is the dividend policy.

3. Protecting Founder Equity: Understanding Vesting Arrangements

One of the most important considerations for a startup with multiple founders is how ownership should be earned and retained over time.

Imagine two founders establish a company and each receives 50% of its shares. One founder works full-time to develop the business, while the other leaves after six months to pursue another opportunity.

The departing founder may still retain their original 50% shareholding, even though they are no longer contributing to the business.

This can create difficulties for the remaining founder and may become a concern for future investors.

4. Good Leaver and Bad Leaver Provisions

Closely related to founder vesting are Good Leaver and Bad Leaver provisions.

These provisions establish how a shareholder’s departure is treated under different circumstances.

For example, a founder may leave because of retirement, illness, permanent incapacity or an agreed change in personal circumstances. Another may leave following serious misconduct or a breach of agreed obligations.

It may not be appropriate to treat both situations in the same way.

Good Leaver

A Good Leaver arrangement may apply where a founder leaves for circumstances recognised as legitimate or acceptable under the agreement.

Depending on the agreement, a Good Leaver may be permitted to retain vested shares or transfer them at a pre-agreed valuation.

Bad Leaver

A Bad Leaver arrangement may apply where a founder leaves in circumstances involving serious misconduct, a material breach of obligations or other specified events.

The agreement may provide for different treatment of their shares, including restrictions on retaining or transferring them.

Any compulsory transfer, buyback or pricing mechanism requires careful legal and financial consideration. In particular, a company purchasing its own shares must comply with the statutory requirements applicable in Hong Kong.

5. Decision-Making Rights and Reserved Matters

As a business grows, not every decision should require approval from every shareholder or every director.

Routine operational decisions can generally be delegated to directors or those responsible for specific business functions. Certain listed reserved matters may require board approval, subject to a defined quorum and voting thresholds, including unanimity where appropriate.

However, certain significant reserved matters may require elevation for shareholder approval in the agreement, again, subject to specified quorum requirements and voting thresholds, including unanimity where appropriate. The aim is to protect shareholders from significant decisions being made without appropriate consideration while allowing the business to operate efficiently. The specific approval arrangements should also be reflected in the Articles where necessary.

Depending on the company’s circumstances, they may include:

  • Issuing new shares or changing the share capital.
  • Bringing in new shareholders or investors.
  • Taking on substantial borrowings.
  • Making significant capital investments.
  • Selling major business assets.
  • Entering into a merger or acquisition.
  • Changing the company’s principal business activities.
  • Approving major related-party transactions.
  • Declaring dividends outside an agreed policy.
  • Appointing or removing key directors or the CFO.

6. Preventing Deadlocks Between Shareholders

A deadlock occurs when shareholders or directors cannot agree on an important decision and the disagreement prevents the company from moving forward.

This is particularly relevant in companies where ownership is divided equally.

For example, two founders each hold 50% of the shares. One wants to invest in a new market, while the other believes the company should conserve its cash.

Neither is prepared to change their position.

Without an agreed resolution process, the company may find itself unable to make important decisions.

A shareholders’ agreement can establish a structured approach to resolving such situations.

7. Protecting Shareholders from Unwanted Ownership Changes

Founders often establish a company with people they know and trust. However, what happens if one shareholder decides to sell their shares?

The remaining shareholders may not want an unknown third party, competitor or unsuitable investor becoming involved in the company.

A shareholders’ agreement can include share transfer restrictions and procedures to address this concern.

8. Tag-Along and Drag-Along Rights: Planning for a Business Exit

As a business becomes more valuable, shareholders may eventually want to sell their investment or accept an offer to acquire the company.

However, different shareholders may have different expectations about when and how to exit.

Tag-along and drag-along provisions can help establish a framework for these situations.

9. Managing Future Investment and Shareholder Dilution

A business may start with two or three founders but eventually require external investment to support expansion.

A new investor may bring additional capital, industry experience, strategic relationships or access to new markets.

However, introducing an investor can change the company’s ownership structure and the rights and relationship of existing shareholders.

For example, if a company issues additional shares to an investor, the founders’ percentage ownership may decrease.

This is known as dilution.

A shareholders’ agreement can address how future investment should be managed internally and externally.

10. Confidentiality, Intellectual Property and Business Protection

Shareholders may have access to sensitive commercial information, including financial reports, customer details, business strategies, pricing information and intellectual property.

A shareholders’ agreement may include confidentiality obligations and other provisions intended to protect the company’s business interests.

For technology businesses, startups and professional services firms, it is particularly important to establish who owns intellectual property created by founders, employees and external contractors.

These arrangements should be considered alongside the company’s other contracts and policies.

11. Why a Well-Structured Shareholders' Agreement Matters to Investors

When a business seeks external investment, prospective investors will often examine more than its revenue, growth potential and financial performance.

They may also want to understand how the company is governed and how shareholder relationships are managed.

A clear shareholders’ agreement can demonstrate that the founders have considered these issues and established a framework for managing them.

It does not guarantee investment or eliminate all future disputes. However, it can help reduce uncertainty and provide greater clarity for existing shareholders and potential investors.

A company that has considered governance arrangements early may also find it easier to manage changes in ownership as it grows.

A Practical Checklist: What Should Your Shareholders' Agreement Cover?

Before finalising your company’s shareholder arrangements, consider whether the following matters have been addressed:

☑ Shareholding percentages and initial contributions.

☑ Founder roles, responsibilities and time commitments.

☑ Founder vesting arrangements, where appropriate.

☑ Good Leaver and Bad Leaver provisions.

☑ Board composition and director appointment rights.

☑ Reserved matters and shareholder approval thresholds.

☑ Deadlock and dispute resolution mechanisms.

☑ Dividend policy and financial reporting arrangements.

☑ Future funding and pre-emptive rights on new share issues.

☑ Share transfer restrictions and Right of First Refusal.

☑ Tag-along and drag-along rights.

☑ Confidentiality and intellectual property protection.

☑ Exit arrangements and share valuation mechanisms.

☑ Consistency with the Articles of Association.

The precise provisions will depend on the company’s ownership structure, business model, commercial objectives and the expectations of its shareholders.

There is no universal shareholders’ agreement that will suit every company.

How Shen LaRoche Can Help with Business Structuring and Advisory

Establishing a company with multiple shareholders involves more than deciding how much each founder will invest.

You also need to consider, document and sign off on the ownership structure; financial arrangements; the balance of power; management responsibilities; and the administrative framework required to operate the business effectively.

At Shen LaRoche, we draw on our extensive practical experience to help entrepreneurs, investors and businesses develop a clear framework for shareholders’ agreements. Our approach aims to minimise the risk of internal disputes by establishing agreed procedures for addressing potential challenges and unforeseen circumstances. More importantly, we identify and recommend the key matters to include, ensuring that the proposed arrangements are practical, relevant and tailored to your business.

As Shen LaRoche is not a law firm, the final version of any shareholders’ agreement should be prepared by appropriately qualified legal professionals before it is signed.

Contact Shen LaRoche to discuss your Back Office and Accounting needs.

WhatsApp: +852 5611 6296 |  info@shenlaroche.com